An American Victory, Studio Cast Recording ~ Concept Album Review

On this trip, all could be lost
To live free, it is worth the cost
Keep your heart strong and be brave
Keep your watch and we will be safe!

There is an evil sailing the waters
Innocent people dying each day
Murderous pirates hold them for ransom
Stealing our ships and demanding we pay

How can we conscience sitting in silence
Paying their bribes and demands?
I say we fight them, no more blood money
Draining our courage and staining our hands!

Oh think about the road you’re on
If it leads where you belong
You will find the truth on your way
Never was a danger born
That could change the right to wrong

What’s in your heart don’t ever betray
Think about your road

Everywhere, there is always someone who is standing beside you
Always there, living on forever in the change that’s inside you
I can hear the call of the voices that rang out long before and
All they’ve won will never be undone
And one day soon a change will come

(From various songs on An American Victory)

Isn’t there just something magnetic (there goes my mathematical brain – for those who wish, you can use the word magical instead) about musicals? Such a glorious way to tell stories via symphonies and melodious phrasing. Sure, you may not get the best character depth or scenery as a book or movie, but I think the beauty of the music and the emotions that talented singers emphasize the lyrics can transport one to an entirely different sphere.

Since April (now infamous for the COVID and lockdowns and all that), I’ve been educating myself on various musicals. I must thank The Story Sponge and all her lovely musical theatre-related posts and playlists and recommends for most of this re-introduction phase. Before this year, I was only very familiar with three that I absolutely loved to re-play: 1) Les Miserables (thanks to the 2012 film starring Hugh Jackman), 2) The Greatest Showman, 3) and A Tale of Two Cities by Jill Santoriello (It’s Sydney Carton. Of course I love it. Especially when sung by a voice James Barbour has.) Fiddler on the Roof, White Christmas, Holiday Inn, Chitty Chitty Bang Bang, Mary Poppins, and The Sound of Music are the other musical films I’ve watched, the first several almost annually. But I’ve never found the soundtrack to be quite so thrilling to replay, since they include a lot of essential visuals.

Now I’ve listened through eleven (almost twelve, since I’m mostly through Annie Get Your Gun) musicals that are new to me. And I love them all, to various degrees. But this is not meant to be a ranking list. Not yet. 😉

Today I’ve to introduce you to a concept musical you’ve most likely not have heard of before. I think it’s the perfect musical for our times. (I stumbled across it myself on Amazon while searching for music performed by Ramin Karimloo (who will always be my favorite male voice in musical theatre, due to, well, The Phantom of course).

Now, this is not a completed musical. Only a concept release. And since I purchased the MP3 album (I consider $8.99 a bargain), I do not have the booklet explaining everything clearly. And whole story is not really apparent via the songs exclusively. Yet I’ve found myself listening to it on repeat just about every time I have my computer music player on at home.

An American Victory is set in 1801, as America experiences brutal attacks on its ships by government sponsored [Mediterranean] pirates, whose extortion demands have grown to reach twenty percent of the entire government’s budget. Based on actual historical events, An American Victory tells the story of an audacious act of defiance against organized terror that forever changes the lives of all those caught in the swirling struggle, and the path of a nation.”

Composer-lyricist Louis R. Bucalo: “The situation and struggle of those who fought this battle in our country’s earliest days is as powerful and resonant now as it was to those who lived it. Once I came to know them, I wanted to tell their story.”

It’s just the concept. The premise. The historical setting. The idea, really, and the individual tracks’ lyrics along with the instrumental and voices (and believe me, each are breathtakingly beautiful, there isn’t a voice on this that I disliked) – those are what makes this entire album glorious for me.

The style is leaning on the legit/classical side – not pop. Plenty of vibrato to lift my heart to soaring (and not excessive, so still conversational).

I didn’t love it the first time through. But the second time through, certain ones struck out at me. And that kept going until I’ve got every single one memorized. I love that American Revolutionary Era setting. The patriotic and fighting spirit. And ships and pirates? Count me in. It’s about fighting against tyranny, for family, for glory, for honor, for freedom. It’s thoroughly hopeful and uniting and victorious, and (I’m so thankful for this aspect) not in the wholly humanistic manner. (It’s not revisionist in its historical aspect, but traditional and true to the times and spirit of the times.) It reminds me that while not every turn in life is happy or what we want, there are so much more in the journey: struggle and hope and journey and grace and courage and redemption and the knowledge that we will see our loved ones again. And that is true joy.

I suppose I took the story the tracks gave me, and added my own details to it. I think over the times I’ve enjoyed the music, I gave the characters more backstory than revealed, and gave them a more vivid future than any laid-out plotline could ever do.

Never really expected all this from simply a concept album, yet that’s what happened. And I’m wondering if that’s unique to me.

I recommend you give it a try. It’s not widely known or mentioned. And I do fervently wish they will find the support to be develop to a stage musical, since I would so love an actual cast of characters and etc., and to be honest I don’t know how long concept albums typically need. But in the meantime: Just listen. And tell me what you think! 🙂 (Hopefully after listening to it a few times.)

Click on the upper right corner for the entire playlist link.


I actually love this album from beginning to end. But some highlights would be: “Glory Bound,” “Revolution,” “The Road You’re On,” “All I Am,” “Please My Love,” “My Child Can You Hear Me?” “Sons of Adventure,” “No Way to Change That Now,” and “A World Away.”

Best Duet:

Most Heartfelt:

What I listen to for waking up:

Have you heard of this musical? What do you think of it? Are you interested enough to listen to it? Can you of think of similar musicals set in this historical era that you like (I’m sure some of you are going to mention Hamilton – allow me to commend that this musical has not a quarter of the content and all of the spirit)? Are there any little-known/mentioned musicals you’d like to recommend?

Let me know in the comments!

12 thoughts on “An American Victory, Studio Cast Recording ~ Concept Album Review

  1. That sounds amazing!! The American Revolution is one of my favorite time periods, and anything about it that is exciting, sincere, and true to the spirit of the times sounds right up my alley! I’ll have to listen to this! Thank you for sharing. 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

        1. I’ve always said that it is no coincidence that Jane Austen was born in 1775. (Have you ever read her Prayer? It’s the best prayer I’ve read other than The Lord’s.)

          I also favor the French Revolution era stories (looking at you, Scarlet Pimpernel and Tale of Two Cities). Recently I started reading a historical fiction series Poldark – the time period i right after the War for Independence and the setting is in Cornwall, England. So far the story and dialogue and characters are gripping, but there are some mature topics. So I probably not do a wholehearted recommend and will try to write a review for it when I finish reading.)

          It’s sad that there are not more musicals set in this time period, though! Are you aware of any?


          1. We have a book of her prayers, but sadly I haven’t read any of them… that I remember. I’ll have to read some of them! Ooh yes, I loved The Scarlet Pimpernel and I’m going to write a review on it soon. I’m excited. 😀

            Oh yes, I’ve heard of Poldark; was interested for a while, but accidentally watched a highly inappropriate scene from the BBC series and decided… ehhh nope, not for me! *cringes*

            No, I’m not, sadly. *thinks really hard*

            Liked by 1 person

            1. I’ve only read one, but it’s beyond comparison:


              Esp. the Pride and Vanity part and “nor be Christians only in name” really gets me.

              Who’s your favorite Janite heroine and hero?

              Yes, I recently finished the TV show. There are more than a few racy scenes we’ve had to skip. However, so far the book does not have any explicit scenes as such, and I admire the way the author handles them. I’ve had several discussions with my mom about the mature topics in the story – overall I’d say it’s well done (other than, you know, the eik parts which are not necessary).

              Liked by 1 person

              1. That was an incredible prayer; thank you so much for sharing it! I’m going to have to print that out and hang it in my room.

                My favorite Austen heroine and hero both happen to appear in the same book… Emma Woodhouse, and Mr. Knightley. A lot of people say Emma is annoying and mean, but I do not find her so, especially after seeing the 2009 BBC miniseries, which does her and Mr. Knightley so much justice. Mr. Knightley is much better than Mr. Darcy, in my own opinion.

                Who is your favorite hero/heroine?

                Ah, I see. That’s good to know. 🙂

                Liked by 1 person

  2. Ah, you are reminding me that I need to listen to this again! I am often unimpressed by things the first time through, (which was true with this one) but I haven’t gotten around to listening again yet. I do want to though. It has a lot of potential, I think.
    I am also just really pleased that I was the one who inspired you to explore more musicals. 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

    1. 🙂 Yes I am! I’m very happy to hear you’re going to try listening to it again! I’ve found this is one of those I can put on repeat without getting tired of it after several months (which is more than I can say for even some of my favorite musicals). ❤

      Oh, absolutely, dear! I am indebted to you and your lovely posts. 🙂 And I shall never fail to recall this fact.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. I haven’t listened to this yet, but I absolutely intend to now. I’m not the biggest fan of musicals, but I do tend to go for the ones where the songs are in a more classical style, and A MUSICAL ABOUT EARLY AMERICAN HISTORY AND THE BARBARY PIRATES???? That is what I was missing in my life, whether I knew it or not. I LOVE stories about cool, less-widely-known pockets of history, that’s a particularly interesting pocket of history, and I feel like pirates and musicals go together really well.

    (Regarding pirates in the Mediterranean, etc, have you ever read Sabatini’s The Sea-Hawk? That’s set in Elizabethan times, so totally different, but it DOES involve Mediterranean pirates! Which I consider thoroughly underrepresented in literature!)

    Also, I will make sure to listen twice. I almost always do. It’s amazing to me how often a second listen catapults a song from “eh, it was fine” to “it’s amazing and quite possibly my favorite.”


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s